Autonomous Car Beta Version, Anyone? A Q&A with Jim Womack on Disruptive Innovation

What may be ahead for carmakers, product developers, and the lean management movement in a tech disrupted world is the subject of this Q&A with management author and expert Jim Womack, founding CEO of the nonprofit Lean Enterprise Institute (LEI). He talked with LEI Communications Director Chet Marchwinski at the Designing the Future Summit [] that showcases how companies are applying lean product and process development (LPPD). The text has been edited for length.

Q: Will the new technologies disrupting the auto industry encourage car companies to be more than car companies by providing not just an automobile but essential services like insurance or delivering the next car we need when it’s needed?

Jim: Well, first I’m not trying to make the world safe for car companies. Maybe we don’t need car companies. Maybe somebody else steps forward. We think the people who are likely to step forward are coming out of the new Silicon-Valley world rather than the old Detroit world. And that’s what’s so scary for the big car companies.

Q: You’ve noted that there’s the auto industry’s response to disruption, and then there’s Toyota’s response to disruption. Toyota is pursuing electric vehicles and hydrogen fuel cells, and self-driving vehicles but also human-driven vehicles with software so humans can’t make a serious mistake. Is Toyota engaging in deep study or early set-based concurrent engineering?

Jim: The key thing Toyota remembered to bring to the party was a whole lot of money, like three times what anybody else has got to play with. That’s company policy going all the way back to its bankruptcy of 1950. They said, “We’re out of cash. We will never run out of cash again.” Therefore, they go into this as a rather cautious company. They like to be a follower actually rather than a leader, technologically. The Prius is the big exception. So, Toyota believes in a portfolio of opportunities and alternatives to experiment with.

Q: You’ve asked product-development teams to rethink how they define customer value during the study phase, the first phase of lean product and process development when teams research the needs of intended customers. What’s the problem that you see?

Jim: In the lean product and process development community we believe in compatibility before completion — before you finalize the design, you make sure the components want to live together. You can’t have software for an autonomous vehicle that sort of works. That’s fine for a social-media app, and that’s where the lean startup movement began with the minimal viable product idea. They pointed out that people were trying to get perfect code before they ever showed it to a customer. Well, I don’t know about you, but I don’t want the beta version of an autonomous vehicle.

Oh, by the way, the same guys who want to bring you autonomy are the guys who brought you handheld electronics that create driver distraction, which is why the death rate is up. But that’s okay because they’re going to provide autonomy, which will take it right back down again. That’s pretty weird.

Q: What do you see as the current state of the lean management movement?

Jim: People thought it was about factories, techniques, and methods – JIT, jidoka, andon, and so forth. It took a long time for people to realize that lean enterprises have interlocking systems, including a product and process development module, a supplier management module, a customer support module, and, sure enough, a production module all wrapped up in a general management concept.

As people tried to apply the tools, typically with consultants in short-term interventions, they discovered that nothing sticks; they were doing kaizen on top of chaos. It turns out that the specific gravity of kaizen is greater than the specific gravity of chaos. So glub, glub, glub, glub, the kaizen disappears.

We now realize that you need the whole system and in particular, you need a management system that can identify problems very quickly and countermeasure them so that you sustain performance. I think we’re making some progress, but it’s never as fast as it should be or as fast as we want it to be.

Keep Learning:
• Get the monthly free newsletter from the Lean Product and Process Development group with how-to content from leading innovation managers who are using LPPD to design better products and services — and better futures for themselves, customers, and employees:
• Join the email list for the latest about the Virtual Lean Summit Experience, including LPPD tracks, coming in the fall 2020:
• In Gemba Walks, Jim Womack illustrates the power of rooting improvement efforts at the “gemba,” a Japanese word referring to the place where work takes place:

You May Also Like